Skip to main content

SHOULD WELSH BUSINESSES HAVE BEEN CLOSED DURING THE FIREBREAK LOCKDOWN?


Last Monday, First Minister Mark Drakeford ordered a “firebreak” lockdown for two weeks to break the spread of coronavirus in Wales. This came into effect yesterday and will last until November 9th.

As a result, people must work from home unless they are critical workers or cannot do their jobs from home and all gatherings with people outside households have been banned. Whilst primary schools will reopen after half term, secondary schools will shut for all but years seven and eight. For businesses, all non-essential retail, gyms, leisure centres, bars, restaurants and hospitality must close for this period.

The rationale for this ‘sledgehammer’ approach of shutting everything down for just over a fortnight through a combination of different measures is that it is the only way to bring down the R rate (i.e. the average number a sick person could pass the virus onto) from its estimated current level of 1.2-1.4 to below 1.0 when the numbers of those infected start to fall.

The scientific evidence behind this decision comes from a paper produced by the Technical Advisory Cell (TAC) which advises the Welsh Government. Interestingly, this shows that the biggest impact on reducing the R rate would come not from shutting businesses but from school closures, managing higher education activities and working from home. 

According to TAC, closing all schools associated would result in a reduction in the R number by up to 0.5 although the political fallout from such a move would be considerable which is probably why this latest lockdown is happening over half-term when schools are shut for part of the time.

Similarly, whilst closing universities could result in a potential reduction in R of 0.3, TAC recommends that there should be a strong steer towards online learning for all but essential practical activities, something which Welsh institutions have already done.

Despite being an integral part of the targeted local lockdowns imposed across Wales, TAC suggests that stopping all contacts between different households in the home might only reduce R by 0.2. In addition, restrictions on outdoor gatherings is likely to be result in only a small reduction in transmission i.e. reducing R by less than 0.05.

So what about the business community? According to TAC, the biggest impact on reducing R within the business community would be more homeworking and if all people who could work from home did so, then there will be a reduction in R of 0.2-0.4.

In contrast, the closure of bars, pubs, cafés and restaurants would only result in a reduction in R of 0.1-0.2. although TAC does argue that the risk could be higher because of the close proximity of people, long duration of exposure and no wearing of face coverings by customers although disappointingly, no mention is made of the extent to which many businesses have gone to make their premises safer to mitigate against these risks.

It is also worth noting that whilst there have been 10pm curfews on bars and restaurants in Wales, the Mayor of London has recently asked for this to be lifted in his city, arguing that there may be little scientific basis for this restriction and that scrapping it would allow more sittings of single households in restaurants throughout the evening. 

In terms of non-essential retail which have also had to shut, there is only a low impact on transmission as the short duration of visits, the ability to distance in most settings and use of face coverings are likely to mitigate well. 

In addition, the closure of gyms will only result in a potential reduction in R of up to 0.1 although a precise estimation is very difficult although it is worth noting that last minute changes this week to restrictions in Tier 3 areas in England means that gyms and leisure centres can actually reopen in Liverpool.

For close-contact personal services such as hairdressing or beauty therapy, TAC argues that whilst each event is likely to be high risk as it involves prolonged, close, face-to-face contact, the use of these services is infrequent so any closure will only have an impact on R of up to 0.05.

Therefore, the scientific evidence seems to suggest that the closure of businesses will only have a small effect on significantly reducing the R number from its current level as compared to other measures. Certainly, those businesses that have done everything possible to ensure the safety of their staff and customers may find it hard to understand why they are again being closed down when the evidence given to the Welsh Government suggests that this may only have a marginal effect on reducing overall transmission rates. 

In its paper, TAC recognises that from an economic perspective, limiting the size of a pandemic related recession will save lives in the future as mortality is closely related to income and life chances. Indeed, the additional support announced by the Chancellor of the Exchequer on Thursday may help businesses to remain viable in the short term and, more crucially, enable them to retain staff. 

However, many will only survive in the future if customers return and will hope that when Wales comes out of this lockdown, the Welsh Government will look again at the scientific evidence in considering a more nuanced national approach that will suppress a coronavirus that will be with us for a considerable period of time whilst minimising the effect on businesses and the economy over the next twelve months.









Popular posts from this blog

THE IMPORTANCE OF FRANCHISING

When we talk about start-ups and entrepreneurship, rarely do we discuss the potential of franchising not only as a way of establishing new ventures in the economy but also as a method of growing existing businesses. According to the British Franchising Association, franchising is the granting of a licence by one person (the franchisor) to another (the franchisee), which entitles the franchisee to own and operate their own business under the brand, systems and proven business model of the franchisor. The franchisee also receives initial training and ongoing support, comprising all the elements necessary to establish a previously untrained person in the business. This enables individuals to start their own businesses without having to develop their own ideas and utilising an existing brand and established market. Of course, whilst each franchise business is owned and operated by the franchisee, the franchisor controls the quality and standards of the way in which the business is

THE MANUFACTURING STRATEGY FOR WALES

Last night, I received the following comment on the previous post relating to a piece I had written back in early 2007 about the state of the manufacturing sector in Wales. "Dylan, you seem to be ignoring the fact that manufacturers in Wales have written the manufacturing strategy. Small and large manufacturers, all represented at the Manufacturing forum, have co-written this strategy. WAG has recently supported this strategy and have funded a co-ordinator with resources. Manufactures are happy with this progress as they are following the strategy they wanted. I know that the Conservatives have attacked the strategy as they seem to think that WAG wrote the strategy. They couldn't be more wrong. The Manufacturing Strategy was written by manufacturers, for manufacturers and is supported by WAG. If you don't agree with this, then I can invite you to the next Manufacturing Forum and you can explain to the manufacturers how their strategy is wrong....I appreciate that there is

THE PERFECT STORM FACING THE UK ECONOMY

In his sublime 1997 book on the fate of the fishing boat Andrea Gale, the author Sebastian Junger defined a “perfect storm” as a rare combination of events or circumstances that results in an unusually bad situation.  This term would not be out of place in describing what is currently happening to the UK economy which is being battered on so many fronts with little respite in sight. For example, the war in Ukraine has had an unexpected impact on energy bills in Europe due to the curtailing of exports from Russia which, last year, was responsible for supplying 40% of all natural gas to the European Union. Whilst the UK is not dependent on Russia for its energy needs, the scramble by other countries to find alternative sources has resulted in higher prices globally which has impacted on the fuel imported by the UK with normal suppliers struggling to meet demand. There have also been considerable supply constraints globally which have been driven by manufacturers struggling to get their g